Sunday, November 22, 2026

Complexity for Complexity's Sake

 Where is the line for you, when it comes to balancing ease of play with realism of the simulation? 

 We've been playing Stargrave the past few weeks in campaign mode. It's a fun skirmish level wargame, and it's dirt simple to play. I've been reading Chainmail again, in order to play it sometime in the near future (still painting fantastic cavalry minis) with the same group of gamers, and while overall it's simple, there are some parts of the game that are, in my opinion, needlessly fiddly. 

For example, there are two types of morale. The post melee morale is fiddly. You need to compare differences in troops lost by each side, then convert that to a chance of routing, then check the dice. The morale check for losing a certain percentage of your force is a 2d6 roll against a set number by troop class. Much simpler (and brought into Basic D&D). I plan to ask the guys if they would house rule to only use the simpler morale check for both post melee and threshold losses checks. We'll see what they say. Alan, I suspect, will want to do things BTB until we've at least given them a fair shot. And that's a fair point.

While waiting for folks to show up for our Missions & Mayhem game this afternoon, I was also thinking about game rules. Obviously, I want things just complex enough in M&M to be interesting, but not so complex as to be burdensome or confusing. I use simple d6 per side initiative, rolled every round, and it works so well. I was thinking back to this post from Chuck the other day about AD&D's initiative rules. 

While many gamers will say that AD&D is great rules-as-written (Hi JB!), and the rules for initiative are not nearly as bad in play as what Chuck describes, they are needlessly complex. Does that extra complexity improve the game play? Sure, it adds some realism in some areas, but it removes it in others. As Chuck mentioned, fighting with a dagger is sub-optimal most of the time, but in rounds where the initiative rolls are tied, you can attack two or three times to the opponent's one attack, making it suddenly the weapon to fight with. In general, I've never found my game to be better off by having to track weapon speed factors 1/6 of the time. 

And that brings me back to Chainmail. I plan to use the mass combat with fantasy supplement rules. But re-reading the man-to-man rules, and again the rules have some complexity with weapon speed/length as well. Maybe it's not needless, but it is definitely fiddly. Now for a war game, where the fight IS the game, it makes sense to want to simulate battle conditions and have tactical and strategic choices around those conditions. But in an RPG, where there is so much more to do than just get into fights, I find that streamlined combat procedures suit me just fine. 

The final example is the Marvel Superheroes RPG. I've been going over those rules, thinking I'd run it at the next TTRPG in Korea Online Con. I've looked over the Basic rules, and the Advanced rules, and the revised rules. The Basic rules are good enough! Maybe if I were going to run a campaign, the Advanced rules would make sense. And I will likely borrow a few things from them. But for a one-shot game, why complicate things? The Basic rules will give me all the rules I'll need for a three to four hour game. 

No comments:

Post a Comment